Search
Advice » CVs & Applications » CV Advice » Why can't I use personal references
CV Advice

Why can't I use personal references

Untitled Document

By Paul W. Barada, Monster Salary and Negotiation Expert

 

How could your sixth-grade teacher, next-door neighbour, or golfing buddy comment on your management style, responsibilities or the quality of your performance on the job?

The answer: They can't.

Often, job seekers think a "personal" reference is someone they've worked with who also happens to be a personal friend. This is normally a business or professional reference because of the work association. Personal references are people with whom you've never worked in a traditional job setting. They include everyone you know, except the people with whom you've actually worked on a day-to-day basis! While that may seem like splitting hairs, there is a difference.

So what's wrong with providing strictly personal references? Nothing, if you're applying for a scholarship, but quite a lot if you're applying for a job. Personal references can only comment on general topics. They might, for instance, be able to say what a nice person you are, what a wonderful sense of humour you have, or how much fun you are at parties, but it is extremely unlikely that a personal reference could possibly be familiar with the sorts of things most employers who check references want to know.

As more and more employers thoroughly check references, everyone who contemplates the possibility of making a career move, regardless of when, should be developing work relationships with superiors, peers, and subordinates who, when needed, can be called upon to serve as references for you.

The dramatic increase in negligent hiring litigation has caused many employers to be far more thorough in checking references. For some employers it is admittedly a perfunctory exercise so they can demonstrate that some sort of minimal effort was made to check a candidate's background before offering a job. However, far more are taking reference checking seriously in terms of carefully evaluating past job performance as it relates to the position the employer wants to fill. That's why your choice of references is more important than ever. Appropriate references can not only enhance your chances for employment, but they can also confirm what you've said about yourself during job interviews.

It is true that many job seekers are willing to take the chance that a prospective employer won't bother to check references. So they provide personal references, references with whom they are barely acquainted or, worse yet, names of people they don't even know but look impressive on a CV. They're hoping they won't get caught and will be able, on the basis of personality alone, to get the job they want. Definitely a dangerous game to be playing.

What could be worse than an employer liking a candidates CV and phone a reference, only to hear: "I don't know why so-and-so listed me as a reference, I barely knew him." Or, "I've never worked with so-and-so, but we play tennis together every week." Those types of responses never enhance employability. Neither does listing an old college roommate who has no clue what you've been doing since graduation. All it does is make your preparation for a career change look sloppy and poorly thought out.

The best way to enhance your future employability is, obviously, to do a good job for every employer. Then, identifying co-workers who can confirm the quality of your job performance should be a relatively simple task. Business and professional references are the ones who will help advance your career. Don't waste a prospective employer's time listing personal references.

Rate this article:
Average rating:
Email to a friend
Share This
Share This

Latest Jobs

Smartsearch Recruitment Ltd
Posted: 16/05/2012
iCore Ltd
Posted: 16/05/2012
West Herts College
Posted: 16/05/2012
C&M Travel Recruitment
Posted: 16/05/2012
Brighton, South ...
Preferred Choice Limited
Posted: 16/05/2012

Want more personalised results?  Update Your Profile

Email to a friend
Share This
Rate this article:
Average rating:
The Monster Forum

Job Interview Q&A

Take a look through some of the questions you might expect to face at a job interview and discuss possible responses with other Monster users.
Join the Discussion

Monster Communities

Graduate Jobs
Graduates! Find jobs and advice in the Monster grad zone.
HM Forces
A growing community of active, retired and prospective soldiers and sailors.
Pro Nurse
A community for active, retired and student nurses.
Public Sector Jobs
Government and public sector jobs and profiles.
More Monster Communities

Monster Partners

learndirect
Flexible e-courses in popular subjects to help you get the right qualifications.
PayScale
Up-to-date salary information in numerous industries and locations.
Home Learning College
Range of courses offered to gain qualifications in various fields.
Skill Studio
Enhance your interview and presentation skills.
More Monster Partners

Searching for Jobs

Job Search Tips
Plan your job search strategy effectively with these tips.

CVs & Applications

CV Tips
Use these handy tips to quickly analyse your CV and update before applying.

Job Interviews

Virtual Job Interview
Interactive tool to help you prepare for multiple questions that you could face on the big day.

Salary & Benefits

Salary Tips
Improve your negotiation skills and learn how to make the most of your current assets.

Attracting Candidates

Job Adverts – Quiz
A clear and concise job advert can help candidates match their skills to the vacancies criteria easily.

Interviewing Candidates

Tips for Small Businesses
If resources are limited, having an effective interview process in place can help cut costs.

Workforce Planning

Engage Using Social Media
Use and interact on Social Media and make the workforce feel a sense of belonging to the organisation.

For Seekers

Career Advice
Browse through a vast selection of content and tools created to aid your career journey.
Career Benchmarking
See how you compare to others in similar fields.
Career Snapshots
Explore new opportunities that you may be perfect for.
Career Services
Give your job search a boost with training and additional courses.
Create a CV
Upload a public CV and let employers find you.
Create a Cover Letter
Stand out from the crowd by including a cover letter in your job applications.
Create a Saved Search
Save a customised search and get jobs emailed straight to your inbox.

For Employers

Career Ad Network
Target your job posting to more candidates on thousands of websites.
Job Postings
Find the right solution for your hiring needs. Starting at £199.
Power CV Search
Monster's new search technology precisely matches people with your jobs.
Resource Centre
Find staffing insights, labour trends, HR best practices and more.
Social Recruiting Solution
Establish your recruitment presence on Facebook and Twitter.
Target Mail
Send targeted emails about your openings to specific groups of candidates on Monster.

Social Media

Job Tweets
Find jobs in your area and industry.
Monster on Facebook
Stay up-to-date with competitions, industry news and general Monster happenings.
Monster on Twitter
Advice, news and Monster support delivered rapidly.
Monster on YouTube
Find advice and how-to guides, past and present ads, interview help and Monster event appearances.
Our Social Network
Browse through the full list of where you can find Monster's offerings
on the web.

Other Links

Advice Forums
Tap into Monster's online career forums and share advice with others.
Career Advice Video Hub
View our collection of videos for advice on various scenarios throughout your career.
Monster Company Profiles
Explore companies and get information to guide your career decisions.
Jobsearch on Mobile
Download the Monster app for iOS and Android.
Jobs & Career Advice
Find jobs in your industry of choice and use the associated resources to boost your search.
Search Jobs:
About Monster | Work for Monster | Advertise with Us | AdChoices | Investor Relations | Social Media
Terms of Use | Privacy Centre | Help | Security | Contact Us | Sitemap | Accessible Site
©2012 Monster - All Rights Reserved - U.S. Patent No. 5,832,497 - NYSE: MWW - V: 2012.5.0.21-220

|Chat With An Employer

Want to Chat With an Employer?

One or more employers would like to chat with you.
or Close